Pyrazole Based Inhibitors against Enzymes of Staphylococcus aureus Computational Study

Pyrazole derivatives display a wide variety of biological activities such as antimicrobial, anti-inflammatory and anti-tumor activities. Its biological prominence has intrigued chemists and biologists in recent years to synthesize new pyrazole derivatives as antiviral, antibacterial and anticancer agents. The current study focuses on molecular docking and dynamics studies of pyrazole derivatives against Nucleosidase and DNA gyrase B of Staphylococcus aureus. Molecular docking and dynamics studies reveal that some of these derivatives show better binding abilities than some of the current drugs available on the market.


Introduction
Staphylococcus aureus (S.aureus) bacterium is involved in a wide range of diseases such as skin infections, endocarditis, meningitis, osteomyelitis, bacteremia, and sepsis. Worldwide, an estimated 2 billion people carry some form of S.aureus; of these, up to 53 million (2.7% of carriers) are thought to carry Methicillin-resistant S.aureus (MRSA) [1]. Treatment for S.aureus infection encountered several roadblocks due to high level of Penicillin, Vancomycin and Methicillin resistance [2]. Hence, there is a requisite for developing new anti-staphylococcal agents. The enzymes DNA gyrase B and Methylthioadenosine / S-Adenosylhomocysteine Nucleosidase (MTAN) are present in bacteria and absent in humans thereby acting as a potential target in treating the S.aureus related diseases.
DNA gyrase is a type II topoisomerase that catalyzes the negative supercoiling of DNA in prokaryotes. It supercoils DNA through a process of strand breakage/resealing and DNA wrapping [3]. Its function is essential to DNA replication, transcription, and bacteriophage λ integrative recombination [4,5]. Its ability to negatively supercoil a relaxed plasmid DNA substrate is unique thus serving as a target for antimicrobial drugs.
MTAN has recently been discovered and it is involved in the quorum sensing pathway of bacteria [6]. Inhibition of MTAN prevents the catalyzing mechanism needed to produce autoinducers which is necessary for the bacterial cells to sense the presence of its population. MTAN also catalyzes the irreversible cleavage of the glycosidic bond in 5'-methylthioadenosine (MTA) and S-adenosylhomocysteine (SAH) [7]. Inhibition of MTAN leads to aggregation of MTA and SAH substrates which in turn inhibits important biological processes in bacteria like polyamine synthesis, methylation, bacterial quorum sensing and methionine recycling [8]. Hence, the absence of MTAN enzyme in mammalian species and its essential role in bacteria has implicated this as a target for antimicrobial drug design [9,10].
Pyrazole and pyrazolones ring system plays an imperative role in wide range of biological activities such as antibacterial [11,12], antifungal [13], antimalarial [14], anticonvulsant, antitumor [15] and anti-inflammatory agents [16]. It is also interesting to note that pyrazoles are reported as well-known pharmacophores in targeting many diseases and in specific a potent Cannabinoid inhibitors are designed using pyrazole scaffold [17][18][19][20]. Several drug compounds such as Cyclooxygenase-2 (Cox-2) inhibitors [21], IL-1 synthesis inhibitors, and protein kinase inhibitors [22] have a 1(H)-phenyl pyrazole motif. Furthermore, few of the 1,5-diarylpyrazole derivatives have been used in combinatorial drugs which exhibit non-nucleoside HIV-1 reverse transcriptase inhibitory activities [23]. Here, in-silico studies were carried with pyrazole derivatives as possible inhibitors against DNA gyrase B and Nucleosidase of S.aureus.

Preparation of protein systems
Part of the preparation is that the bond orders were assigned, disulphide bonds were created and hydrogens were added to the PDB structures. Restrained impref minimization with default settings was performed on the structure with optimized potentials for liquid simulations (OPLS) 2005 force field. The resulting structures were used for protein docking.

Molecular docking
The compounds intended to be used for docking were prepared using default protocol of the Ligprep program [25] in the Schrödinger's suite 9.3. Glide 5.8 program in the Schrödinger's suite 9.3 was used for docking studies. Hierarchical series of filters to search for possible locations of the ligand in the active site region of the drug target is used by Glide (Grid based LIgand Docking with Energetics) [26,27]. Pyrazole compounds were docked to the target protein using the Induced Fit docking (IFD) protocol. G-score and E-model scores were used as ranking criteria for the best docked ligands. Initially, 30 geometrically possible poses per compound were segregated and used for analysis.

Molecular dynamics
Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were performed using Desmond 3. 2 [28] incorporated into the Schrödinger suite 9.3 [29]. Each simulation was carried out for 5 nanoseconds (ns). The OPLS 2005 [30] molecular mechanics force field is used for minimization and simulation. The pose with best E-model was considered for MD simulation studies. The complexes were solvated using the Desmond protocol resulting in a cubic box of 10 × 10 ×10 nm 3 . For the water molecules the simple point charge (SPC) model was used. The simulation was conducted at an ionic strength of 150 mM, which was obtained by adding sodium and chloride ions (gyrase system: 22 NaCl molecules; MTAN system: 26 NaCl molecules). Additional sodium ions were added to neutralize the systems (DNA gyrase system: 7 sodium ions; MTAN system: 10 sodium ions). Energy minimization of 1000 steps using steepest descent was carried out to release the system from its conflicting contacts. The MD simulations were performed for i) DNA gyrase complex (30916 atoms) and ii) MTAN complex (28772 atoms). SHAKE algorithm [31] was used to constrain the geometry of water molecules and hydrogen bonds. A cutoff of 9 Å was used for the short-range interactions. Electrostatic interactions were calculated using smooth particle mesh Ewald method [32]. Periodic boundary conditions were applied in x, y, and z directions. The NVT (constant number of atoms N, volume V and temperature T) ensemble was used for the simulations. Temperature was set to 300 K and regulated by the Noose Hover thermostat using a relaxation time of 1 pico second. A time step of 1.2 femto seconds was applied. Configurations were saved every 4.8 pico seconds. Root mean square displacement (RMSD) was calculated by fitting alpha carbons of the particular frame of interest with the structure from the first time frame. Trajectories were analyzed between 2 to 5 ns.

Results and Discussion
The three dimensional x-ray structures of DNA gyrase B (PDB ID: 3G7B) and MTAN (3BL6) of S.aureus, retrieved from the Protein Data Bank are shown in Figures 1 and 2 along with its active site residues. DNA gyrase B and MTAN were solved in complex with its respective inhibitors namely, Ciprofloxacin and Formycin A. These complex structures reveal essential interactions between the inhibitor and the protein and these interactions are taken as the reference for the pyrazole derivative that has been elucidated in our lab. The residues of DNA gyrase B such as Glu50, Asn54, Glu58 and Thr173 present in the ATP binding pocket are involved in ATPase activity [33]. The co-crystallized ligand are forms hydrogen bond interaction with the residues Asp81, Ser129 and Leu138 ( Figure 1B) which are present within the ATP binding pocket. The ligand is also further stabilized by a number of hydrophobic contacts with the residues Ile86, Pro87, Ile102, Leu103 and the side chain of Arg86.
Similarly the residues Glu11, Ser75, Glu173, Asp196 and Phe150 frame the ribose binding site of MTAN. The co-crystallized ligand forms several hydrogen bonds with the residues of Ser75, Glu171, Glu173, Asp196 and polar backbone atoms of Ile151 and Met172. Phe150 forms The eight pyrazole derivatives shown in Figure 3 were taken for docking studies. These compounds are synthesized and their structures have been determined by X-ray crystallography [34][35][36][37][38][39][40][41]. The authors propose that these compounds could show inhibitory activity against DNA gyrase B and MTAN of S.aureus. The docking studies clearly reveal that some of these compounds bind efficiently to the enzymes of S.aureus. Glide E-model varies between -55 to -88 for compounds 1-8 tested for DNA gyrase B and -56 to -120 for MTAN ( Table 1). Out of the eight pyrazole derivatives analyzed, compound A and compound H forms the best interaction with DNA gyrase B and MTAN respectively.

Interaction of the best performing pyrazole derivative with DNA gyrase B
The compound A has the highest Glide E-model score of -88. 24. The oxygen atom forms hydrogen bond with the nitrogen atom of Arg84 (~3.1 Å) (Figure 4). Compound D having a Glide E-model score of -85.67, makes hydrogen bonds with the active site residue Thr173 and Asp81 of DNA gyrase B (Figure 1, Supplementary material). The oxygen atom of compound D forms a hydrogen bond with the side chain carboxylate group of Asp81 (1.94 Å) (Figure 1

Interaction of the best performing pyrazole derivative with MTAN
The Compound F and H form the best interactions with MTAN of S.aureus. The Compound F form hydrogen bonds with Glu11, Ser75 and Arg192 of MTAN with the Glide E-model of -118.44. The compound F being small and compact binds deeper inside the active binding pocket of this enzyme with almost occupying the entire surface area of the pocket. The furan ring of the compound F forms π-π stacking interaction with the hydrophobic residue, Phe150 of MTAN. Apart from this, hydrophobic interactions are observed between the compound H -Phe206 and Compound H -Leu210 which also contributes to the stability of this complex.
On the other hand the compound H being a very big hydrophobic compound could not make any hydrophilic interaction with the defined active site residues. The MTAN -Compound H complex is mostly stabilized by hydrophobic and van der Waals interactions resulting in a Glide E-model of -119.65. Though a part of the molecule went deep into the pocket, the entry of the other half of the molecule is blocked by the presence of bulky benzene ring in the structure as indicated in Figure 5 (Phe150 and Phe206). Although the compound H has polar atoms which can accept hydrogen bonds from the receptor molecule, the presence of bromo-benzene and two other phenyl rings in the Compound H structure blocked the full entry of the molecule deep into the active site. Benzene ring in compound H displays π-π stacking with Phe-150. This π-π stacking plays a vital role in providing stability to the Compound H -MTAN complex.
In order compare the binding mode of pyrazole derivative with the already established inhibitor for this enzyme, Formycin A, a transition state analog (Figure 3

Molecular dynamics simulation
Stability of DNA gyrase -compound A and MTAN -compound H complex were evaluated through 5 ns molecular dynamics (MD)   Root mean square fluctuation (RMSF) is calculated for the DNA gyrase B -compound A and MTAN -compound H complexes. The RMSF is useful for characterizing local changes along the protein chain (Figure 7). Side chain fluctuations are observed within <3Å region. With few exceptions, remaining >95% of residues fluctuate within the region of 0.4 -1.5 Å. In Figure 7 A, peaks with RMSF >1.2 Å are observed at region around Gly105, Met204 and Asn17. This is expected, since these residues are located in loop regions. In contrary, small peaks around the regions of Asn54 and Glu58 are observed indicating that there are considerable contacts during the simulation of DNA gyrase B. Glu58 maintains at least 2 contacts in the simulation ( Figure 6A, Supplementary material). Glu58 maintains 52% of contacts throughout the simulation ( Figure 6B, Supplementary material). Contacts between the compound and the residues Asn54 and Arg144 is established by water molecules ("water bridge") at 33% and 35% respectively ( Figure  6B, Supplementary material). In the simulation on the MTANcompound H complex, Glu11, Phe150 and Arg192 show respectively 2-3, 2 and 1 contacts throughout the simulation. Other residues which simulations. Analysis was performed between 2 and 5ns. Root mean square displacement (RMSD) values of the DNA gyrase and MTAN Cα atoms and its respective ligands during the production phase relative to its starting structures are shown in Figure 6. Both complexes were stable, and RMSD of the Cα atoms in the proteins varied ~1Å, which is in the range commonly observed in protein simulations. The relatively large RMSD value for the compound is caused by the flipping of its benzyl ring at the start of the simulation to make π-π interactions with Phe206. The shift of ligand movement up to 4Å is due to the flipping of one benzene ring while the rest of the ligand remains in the initial position and is stabilized by hydrogen bonds. The neighboring interacting residues with compound A and H are shown in (Figure 4  show good contacts over a long simulation period are Phe206, Leu210 and Ile49 ( Figure 7A, Supplementary material). Phe150 -compound H interactions are driven by π -π interactions. Phe150 interacts 52% and 34% of the simulation time with the benzene rings of compound H ( Figure 7B, Supplementary material).

DNA gyrase -Compound A
The docking and MD simulation observed the possible residues involved in binding of Compound A to DNA gyrase. The interacting residues which were observed during IFD docking were also found replicating the interactions during simulation (Figure 8). In the above plot, we can find the hydrogen bond interaction of Glu58 (32%) and Asn54 (1.2 %) with Compound A. Since water molecules are included in the simulations, we were able to obtain this interaction through water bridge Asn54 (20 %). The hydrophobic contacts of residues Arg86 (21%), Ile102 (14 %) displayed during docking were also consistent throughout the simulation. The hydrogen bonds formed by Glu58 and Asn54 remained intact throughout the simulation ( Figure 8A). We were able to observe that the residues Asn54, Gly85 and Arg144 displayed 33%, 6%, and 35% contacts with the ligand during the simulation.

MTAN -Compound H
The residues Glu11 (90%), Ser75 (18%) and Arg192 (100%) of MTAN displayed consistent hydrogen bond interactions with compound H. Residues Ser195 (17%) and Ser75 (9%) interact with the compound via water bridges. The hydrophobic interactions which is calculated for residues Ile49 (51%), Phe150 (85%), Phe206 (52%) and Leu210 (43%) are within 3.6 Å. The hydrophobic interactions of Compound H contribute the stability in the binding pocket is displayed by the π-π interaction of the benzene ring with residues Phe-150 and Phe-206 of MTAN. There are also some ionic interactions displayed by the residues Glu211 and Arg192 respectively. The residues Glu11, Phe150 and Arg192 maintain the contacts with the compound H at 100%, 52% and 90% respectively during the entire simulation. In order to compare pyrazole derivatives for its efficiency standard drugs Ciprofloaxcin and Formycin A shown in Figure 1c and 2c is included in our docking studies. The above established enzymeinhibitor complex is taken as a model for explaining our pyrazole derivatives interaction with the active sites of the enzyme MTAN and DNA gyrase B of S.aureus. MD simulations of these best compounds (compound A-DNA Gyrase B and Compound H-MTAN) help us to understand the interactions of the protein-ligand complex in a better way. From our MD results we are able to describe water bridges observed with the residues of Arg-144 in DNA gyrase complex.

Conclusion
Through Molecular docking and dynamics studies, it was clear that among the eight pyrazole derivatives, the compound A, D, F and H shows better binding to DNA gyrase B and MTAN of S.aureus. The docking studies with the pyrazole derivatives showed that our derivatives also established a similar way of binding with the target protein which is explained by their comparable binding energy and interaction with the active site residues of the enzymes. To both of the target proteins, the phenol and the pyrazole ring plays a vital role in holding the molecule in place by forming hydrogen bond with the active site residues. Thus, the newly derived pyrazole derivatives show better mode of binding than the already available inhibitor and our finding will help in designing a novel anti-staphylococcal agents.